B
BlackVoteWatch

UNLISTED PREVIEW · Not linked anywhere and not indexed. Anyone with this URL can view it — don't share it.

← Statewide Races

How Statewide Races Works

This page exists so you can check our work. It explains why a candidate appears, why another doesn't, and what has to be true before we publish a claim about anyone.

Why statewide, and why governor first

BlackVoteWatch began with Congress because congressional accountability is countable — roll-call votes are public and attributable. Governors are harder. They don't vote; they sign, veto, appoint, and budget. There is no scoreboard to scrape, which is precisely why so little of this gets tracked.

We started with governors rather than every statewide office because the governorship concentrates the most power over things that directly shape Black life in a state: Medicaid, voting legislation, judicial and election-board appointments, and the budget. Attorney general, secretary of state, and legislative races matter too. They are out of scope for now on purpose — we would rather cover one office well than five badly.

Publication states

Every candidate we evaluate lands in one of three states, and that state controls what you see.

  • •Full dossier. We have enough sourced evidence to characterize the candidate's record fairly. They get a full page with a status, receipts, and a rhetoric-versus-record section.
  • •Stub. The candidate qualifies for coverage but does not yet meet the evidence threshold for a full dossier. They appear on the race hub with their name, office sought, and party — marked Needs More Evidence — with no status and no page of their own. We do not create placeholder dossier pages.
  • •Invisible. The candidate does not meet the qualification bar. They do not render anywhere.

The point of the stub state is to make it possible for us to be honest about uncertainty instead of padding a page. If we can't back it, we don't claim it.

How a candidate qualifies

Coverage requires both of the following. Failing either one means the candidate stays unpublished.

1. Eligibility. The candidate is formally declared, or is an incumbent clearly running for re-election, or is broadly treated by credible state-level coverage as an active top-tier contender.

2. Viability — at least two of these four signals:

  • •Fundraising relevance. Enough money raised to be treated as a real competitor in the context of that race — not symbolic campaign noise.
  • •Party backing or institutional support. Meaningful support from state party actors, major endorsers, or visible institutional or movement backing of clear consequence.
  • •Credible race inclusion. Consistent treatment in reputable state or national coverage as part of the real field — not a fringe mention.
  • •Ballot or procedural legitimacy. Ballot access, presumptive ballot relevance, or other procedural standing that makes the campaign real.

This checklist is an internal editorial tool, not a public scorecard. We publish the rules so you can hold us to them, but we don't display per-candidate signal counts — the goal is consistency, not theatrics.

We do not use polling as a qualification signal. Polls measure attention, not accountability.

What it takes to publish a full dossier

Qualifying gets a candidate onto the race hub. Moving from a stub to a full dossier requires all of the following:

  • •At least one primary or official source establishing core identity and campaign status.
  • •At least two corroborating sources behind any consequential claim.
  • •Enough material to fill every core dossier section properly — race stakes, rhetoric, actual record, money and power network, contradictions, and receipts.
  • •A watch status the evidence can actually support, rather than one inferred from vibes.

If a candidate matters enough to acknowledge but not enough to analyze fully, we publish the stub. If they don't clear the checklist at all, we publish nothing.

Evidence hierarchy

Every receipt on a dossier carries a tier. The tier tells you how much weight the claim can bear.

  • Tier 1Primary sources. Government records, contracts, filings, court documents, official statements, and direct analysis of public records.
  • Tier 2Original reporting from established news organizations with named sourcing or firsthand documentation.
  • Tier 3Secondary reporting and aggregation that relies on other outlets' work.
  • Tier 4Advocacy material, opinion writing, and partisan commentary. Useful for context, never sufficient on its own.

No serious red-flag claim on this site rests on Tier 3 or Tier 4 evidence alone. If that's all we have, the candidate degrades to a stub instead.

What the status labels mean

  • •On Watch. There is something specific and documented worth following, but not yet a pattern we'd characterize as harmful.
  • •Concerning. The documented record includes conduct or positions that we believe cut against Black interests, and the sourcing is strong enough to say so plainly.
  • •Strong on Paper, Weak in Practice. The candidate has a genuine record of advocacy alongside a documented record of acting against the communities they claim to represent. Both halves are real.
  • •Needs More Evidence. Not a dossier status — it is the stub display state. It means this candidate is relevant enough to track in the race, but there is not yet enough verified material to publish a full accountability dossier. It is a research-completeness threshold, not an editorial verdict, and it implies nothing about a candidate either way.

A status is a description of a record. It is not a prediction, not a grade, and not an endorsement or its opposite.

The three real statuses appear only on full dossiers, never on stubs. A stub carries no status at all — that is the point of it.

What this section is not

  • ×Not polling coverage. We publish no polls or odds.
  • ×Not predictions. We don't forecast winners.
  • ×Not campaign-theater coverage. Gaffes, ads, and rally crowd sizes aren't accountability.
  • ×Not a party scorecard. Democrats appear here with the same scrutiny as Republicans, and our first two dossiers reflect that.

Found something we got wrong? We'd rather fix it than defend it.

Send a correction